CBC NEWSWORLD

IN THE NEWS

World

Photo Galleries

ANALYSIS

Why Vladimir Putin's Crimea victory may be the end of Russia's Ukraine blitz

The real prize is Kyiv, and the negotiations have already begun

By Nahlah Ayed, CBC News Posted: Mar 19, 2014 5:00 AM ET Last Updated: Mar 19, 2014 8:37 AM ET

From left, Crimea's Prime Minister Sergei Aksyonov, parliamentary speaker Vladimir Konstantinov, a solemn Vladimir Putin and Sevastopol Mayor Alexei Chaliy attend an elaborate, state broadcast signing ceremony at the Kremlin on Tuesday, making the Ukrainian Black Sea peninsula a part of Russia. (Sergei Ilnitsky / Reuters)

Say what you like about Vladimir Putin. But his appearance at a joint session of Russia's parliament Tuesday was brilliantly staged.

It was, after all, a speech certain to be watched around the world. It had to look historic.

This was, of all moments, the one for Putin to put an end to any doubt about his intentions — not that there was very much out there — and sign a declaration making Crimea part of the Russian Federation.

In the Kremlin, the camera shots were expertly cut to take in the whole scene and reinforce the key messages Putin was sending the world: the grandeur of the ornate chandeliers, the religious minorities sitting in the crowd, the flags on either side of him.

One thing that didn't have the appearance of being staged was the joy in that room.

Look at these events, for a moment, from Putin's perspective.

A man who has long lamented the fall of the Soviet Union, he finally managed to bring a serious piece of it back to the Russian fold — and without a single loss of Russian life.

No small feat. No wonder he's apparently doing so well in the polls.

And given the mostly lacklustre response from the West — many admonitions, sanctions against a small handful of Russian officials and vague threats of G8 expulsion — no wonder he doesn't look worried.

Ultimately, with Crimea now firmly in Russia's sphere, and Kyiv in the West's, the only way out of this is negotiation and diplomacy. The wheels are already in motion.

NO WAR OVER CRIMEA

Putin's confidence at this point rests on his argument that Crimea's departure from Ukraine to join Russia meets international legal tests, despite what Western governments say.

He is relying on the notion that it was Crimea's semi-autonomous government that decided to hold Sunday's referendum, and that it was a majority of Crimea's people who voted resoundingly and of their free will to join the Russian Federation.

People in Sevastopol, Crimea, some waving the former flags of the Soviet Union, watch a broadcast of Russian President Vladimir Putin's address to the Federal Assembly on Tuesday, after he signed a treaty making Crimea part Russia. ( Baz Ratner / Reuters)

The outcome — 96.7 per cent in favour — was "more than convincing," Putin said yesterday.

There was little mention of the way the new Crimean government was formed in the wake of Kyiv's revolution — without Ukrainian participation; the absence of debate prior to the referendum vote in Crimea's parliament; the apparent barring of a Tatar Muslim member from voting on the referendum bill; and the fact that two Ukrainian television networks were unplugged on Crimean television, while a Russian station was added, leading up to the vote.

Of course Putin also outright denied — and still denies — that there were Russian soldiers on the ground in Crimea, forming the menacing backdrop to the political machinations.

But none of that matters to him now. With the overwhelming referendum vote, Putin clearly feels he is on safe legal ground.

He also knows the West ultimately won't fight over Crimea, especially if Kyiv is the prize.

STILL IN THE G8?

Putin probably also calculates that while the big Western democracies might suspend Russia from participating in some of the upcoming G8 meetings, they are not likely to expel it, much as some of them might want to.

Russia joined the G8 in 1998 on U.S. encouragement, bolstered by the support of several member countries, including Canada.

The idea was that the benefits of including Russia in the exclusive club would be better than excluding it. Better politically, better for stability, potentially, one day, even better economically for all concerned.

Most G8 members probably still believe that is the case, despite Crimea. A quick look at a world map suggests why: Russia is still crucial to some of the world's big problems: Syria and Iran, to name just a couple.

Most of those European G8 countries also have strong economic ties with Russia, either as energy importers or as financial centres, that they don't want to mess with.

While some, like Canada, may be more hawkish on Russia, they will likely be forced to toe the line, if only to preserve some semblance of Western unity.

Meanwhile, in a more austere setting, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry discussed the sanctions against Russia during a town hall meeting at the State Department in Washington on Tuesday. (Yuri Gripas / Reuters)

So the strong likelihood is that the G8 club will go some way in forcing Putin to pay for his Crimean grab, short of throwing him out.

Not unless Putin continues on a quest to bring more pieces of Soviet Russia back. Not unless he rushes into Eastern Ukraine to protect Russian rights there too.

Many diplomats and defence analysts are fairly certain he won't do that.

But he still keeps threatening to.

While he has repeatedly said that he has no plans of invading Eastern Ukraine, which also has a large contingent of Russian speakers, he has also insisted he retains the option should Russians there require his protection.

That option is unlikely as it would certainly elicit a much stronger response from the West.

But Putin's positioning provides the outlines for a deal, which has been taking shape right from the start, even as Russian troops were making their presence felt in Crimea.

Putin has apparently indicated to Germany's Angela Merkel that he may be satisfied with the idea of international military observers, forcefully barred from Crimea two weeks ago, going into Eastern Ukraine to look into Russian minority rights there.

Their presence on the ground — unarmed, small and ultimately symbolic — would still give the impression the West has managed to "do something" concrete about the worst crisis Europe has faced in some time.

In the absence of a will on both sides to actually go head to head over this crisis, symbolism — and stage management — is everything.

font images google

font redaction cbc.ca/news/world/why-vladimir-putin-s-crimea-victory-may-be-the-end-of-russia-s-ukraine-blitz-1.2577873

Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Pet Shop Boys - Go West

Go eastern

Go West

(Together) We will go our way

(Together) We will leave some day

(vamos, vamos, vamos, vamos, vá para o oeste!)

(Together) Your hand in my hand

(Together) We will make our plan

(Together) We will fly so high

(Together) Tell all our friends goodbye

(Together) We will start like new

(Together) This is what we'll do:

(Go west) Life is peaceful there

(Go west) in the open air

(Go west) where the skies are blue

(Go west) this is what we're gonna do

(Together) We will love the beach

(Together) We will learn and teach

(Together) Change our pace of life

(Together) We will work and thrive

(I love you) I know you love me,

(I want you) how could I disagree?

(And that's why) I make no protest

(And you say) you will do the rest

(Go west) life is peaceful there

(Go west) in the open air

(Go west) baby, you and me

(Go west) this is our destiny

(Go west) sun and winter time

(Go west) we will do just fine

(Go west) where the skies are blue

(Go west) this is what we're gonna do

There, where the air is free

We'll be (we'll be) what we want to be

Now, if we make a stand

We'll find (we'll find) our promised land!

(I know that) there are many ways

(To live there) in the sun or shade

(Together) we will find the place

(To settle) where there's so much space

(Don't look back) And the place back east

(Wrestling) wrestling just to feast

(And we'll go) ready to be two

(So that's what) we are gonna do

(Oh, what we're gonna do is...)

(Go west) life is peaceful there

(Go west) there, in the open air

(Go west) Where the skies are blue

(Go west) This is what we're gonna do...

(Life is peaceful there) Go west

(In the open air) Go west

(Baby, you and me) Go west

(This is our destiny) Come on, come on, come on, come on

(Go west) Sun and winter time

(Go west) we will feel just fine

(Go west) where the skies are blue

(Go west) this is what we're gonna do

(Come on, come on, come on, come on, go west!)

Fonte credit- Redactor

Fonte image - Google and youtube

AJE - Al Jazeera Inglês -

Cbs -

Fox News -
CNN -

Bbc London -

La nacion argentina -

Reuters London - El diary -
La time -
La razón (Bolivia)

Last Minute Spain)

20 Minutes (Barcelona)
20 Minutes (Madrid)

172 Comments

'Dude' Skytalker

Uhmm.. sorry missed. What channel is the that again and will it interfere with my shows?

24 minutes ago
0 Likes

ddazuk

Rather then have CBC tell you all what to think why not read Putin's speech?
You can find it all here in English
http://praguepost.com/eu-news/37854-full-text-of-putin-s-speech-on-crimea
A brilliant articulate speech if I may say so?
And yes I read it entirely

28 minutes ago
3 Likes

williammorgan

Could the use of the word blitz in the headline be a bit of propaganda?

28 minutes ago
0 Likes

Eye1derWho

It is clear that Putin plans to keep Crimea regardless of economic & political posturing by the US & EU (Canada imo is distant background noise in this affair). Now what is Putin's appitite re other boarder states?? Putin needs buffer states that govern in the same manner he governs. Putin cannot have what goes on in the media or politicis of the recently freed Hungry, Poland, Czech or Solvak happening in downtown Moscow any time soon. Putin & Russia need like minded states functioning in the... » more

29 minutes ago
0 Likes

Canadian Guy

Ukranian TV chief viciously attacked yesterday by Svoboda MP and later kidnappedhttp://huff.to/1fFIk0U
Is this ok? Why is it not getting airtime or coverage?

31 minutes ago
1 Like

Flag

'Dude' Skytalker

Life is short and then you get hemmorrids - so crack a smile like any buttonhole would.

32 minutes ago
1 Like

WooooHoooo

If Russia hadn't violated the 1994 non-proliferation agreement and left their base, there would have still been a pro Ukrainian head of Crimea and no Referendum to join Russia.

The overthrow in Kiev was citizens taking over a government that was not representing its people, a value and right that democratic countries hold dearly. A coup is not the same.

Why not give Putin a peace prize maybe that will distract him from taking more land for a while.

34 minutes ago
1 Like

Simple Man

Seriously, who are the clowns in 'western government' who decided to pull this stupidity?

They should be fired and never listened to again.

This here is a direct result of meddling, instigated by the west, timed during Putin's Olympics.

It seems the reason Victoria Nuland insulted the EU is because they were not on board to 'do this thing'. Canada and the US have absolutely no business in the region. This is on Europe's borders, Russia's borders, and involves a country caught in the... » more

34 minutes ago
0 Likes

'Dude' Skytalker

Word on the street, don't swallow the red pill or you'll wake up a communist.

37 minutes ago
0 Likes

scottdr33

There are still Russian speakers in Alaska. Will Putin move to protect them? Is he regretting the czars sale of it? I'd love to see him try that one.

43 minutes ago
4 Likes

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.